Reform Advocacy – Migrant Child Labor in the United States
Kyle Huffman • June 15, 2023
On February 25, 2023, the New York Times published a compelling piece
by journalist Hannah Dreier, exploring the topic of the exploitation of migrant children by major corporations in the United States.
In the article, The Times interviewed more than 100 migrant child workers in 20 states in the United States. The breadth and diversity of the jobs held by these children is truly shocking, and a depressing number of these jobs are in highly dangerous environments. There are examples of young migrants cleaning meatpacking plants at night after a full school day, stacking metal castings at the Hyundai Motor Group, and working 12-hour shifts at a conveyor belt packaging cereals and snack products, among many other dangerous and labor-intensive positions.
Most reasonable people will hear this news and immediately understand just how troubling this situation is and see the immediate need to make efforts to correct these unjust and horrific practices. But what can be done to address this situation?
According to NPR’s congressional correspondent Claudia Grisales, “It's going to be a really, really tall order for Congress. Republicans say that a crackdown on border security is the answer here. And several noted that the House Judiciary Committee will now begin work on a GOP border security bill, but we do not expect that to go far with a Democratic-controlled Senate and White House. House Democrats are asking for a bipartisan solution, but that's going to be really difficult for Congress to get on the same page here.”
In my view, it is the wrong approach to focus on border security to address these issues. Sure, changes to border security may positively impact this negative situation, but it would be far better to approach a resolution from the other side of this equation: going after the large corporations who are hiring migrant children in violation of the law. Changes to the United States border security policy will not address the underlying economic challenges that have resulted in record numbers of unaccompanied minors showing up at the United States’ southern border. Policy of separating children from their parents, which is quite horrific, was enforced by the prior presidential administration, and still, record numbers of individuals undertook the treacherous journey to the United States.
Rather than punishing children and families seeking a better life, the United States should focus on punishing companies turning record profits by exploiting these families by violating labor laws. It is worth noting that several of the corporations mentioned in the articles are currently under investigation by the U.S. Department of Labor, and greater consequences may still be seen. However, in the case of the Hyundai Glovis Facility in Alabama, so far the only punishments issued have been to the three staffing agencies hired by Hyundai to staff the facility, each of which were fined only $5,050. Hyundai’s use of staffing agencies has enabled the company thus far to escape liability for profiting off illegal child labor by placing the blame for these law violations on the staffing agencies hired. If the United States is looking for potential solutions to this widespread issue, one avenue would be to start here. The United States could close the existing legal loopholes that allow major corporations to escape liability for their exploitative practices, and instead impose strict penalties, which is far more likely to result in significant positive outcomes. In addition, harsh financial penalties for this type of labor law violation could be used to support the programs within the United States Department of Health and Human Services, which is responsible for caring for unaccompanied minors in the United States.
In 2022, the same year these labor practices were revealed in news media, and Hyundai’s staffing agencies took action resulting in them having to pay a total of $15,150 in penalties, Hyundai reported a 47% increase in operating profit to $7.35 Billion. In looking for solutions to what are clearly major problems for the United States, perhaps the United States should start by making the companies with hundreds of millions, if not billions of dollars in resources take greater care in their hiring policies and imposing harsh financial penalties for violation of the labor laws by hiring undocumented and underage workers. No company doing business in the United States should be able to profit billions of dollars off the exploitation of illegal child labor. Enhancing the financial punishment of companies found to be engaging in these practices would have the twofold effect of deterring labor law violations by making the punishment potential more daunting than the profit potential, and simultaneously creating a new source of funding to support the programs charged with caring for these vulnerable individuals by utilizing any financial penalties imposed.
This blog is not intended to be legal advice and nothing here should be construed as establishing an attorney client relationship. Please schedule a consultation with an immigration attorney before acting on any information read here.

A letter from USCIS asking for more evidence can be unsettling, especially after months of waiting. A Request for Evidence, commonly called an RFE, gives you an opportunity to address questions about your immigration application or petition. It is not a final denial, but it requires a timely and carefully prepared response.

An artist receives an invitation to join a new production. A business professional is offered a consulting role alongside an existing position. A musician wants to perform for several organizers during the same season. For professionals whose careers involve multiple projects, an important immigration question often follows: can an O-1B visa cover work for more than one employer? The answer can be yes, but the employment arrangements must be covered by the appropriate petition structure. An O-1B approval does not provide unrestricted permission to accept any job in the United States. Your approved work arrangements matter The O-1B category allows qualifying individuals with extraordinary ability or achievement to work in their area of expertise. However, eligibility based on professional accomplishments is only part of the case. The petition must also establish the proposed work and the relationship between the professional and the petitioner. Before accepting an additional position, your attorney should review who filed the existing petition, the work it covers, and how the proposed opportunity fits into that arrangement. A valid visa and an unexpired approval notice do not answer those questions on their own. Separate employers or an agent petition When an O-1B beneficiary works for multiple employers during the same period, each employer generally files a separate petition unless an established U.S. agent files a petition covering the arrangement. An agent petition can be useful when a professional’s work involves several employers or engagements. Depending on the arrangement, the agent may act as an actual employer as well or only represent the employers and the professional. The petition must document the agent’s role and the proposed employment. For an agent petition involving multiple employers, the supporting documents include contracts and an itinerary identifying the engagements, their dates, the actual employers, and the locations where services will be performed. Your attorney will determine the documentation needed for your particular structure. A new opportunity may require another filing If you change employers while in the United States, a new petition is generally required. When the original case was filed through an agent, an amended petition may be necessary to address the new employer. Material changes to the approved employment terms can also require an amendment. There is a specific provision allowing petitioners for artists and entertainers to add qualifying performances or engagements during the petition’s validity without an amended petition. That flexibility should not be treated as blanket permission to change employers or accept unrelated work. Your attorney should assess whether it applies to the proposed engagement. Review the opportunity before agreeing to a start date A promising offer can come with a short deadline. Sharing the proposed contract, duties, employer information, and anticipated dates with your attorney early can help clarify the immigration requirements before business commitments are made. Your attorney will confirm whether the work is already covered, whether another petition is needed, and when you may begin. Do not assume that submitting a new petition automatically authorizes work for the new employer. Contact Santos Lloyd Law Firm, P.C. If you believe you may qualify for the O-1B status and to discuss a filing strategy that fits your professional plans.


